John Magaro
John Robert Magaro (born February 16, 1983) is an American actor. He starred in the films Not Fade Away and First Cow. He also had supporting roles in Unbroken, The Big Short, Carol, Overlord and the Netflix series Orange Is the New Black and The Umbrella Academy. He made his Broadway debut as Earl Williams, the escaped convict, in the hit revival of The Front Page in 2016.
Acted in
The Bride!
2025
Day of the Fight
2024
September 5
2024
as Geoff
The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write about a Serial Killer
2024
as Keane
LaRoy, Texas
2024
as Ray
Under the Boardwalk
2023
as Manny (voice)
The Mistress
2023
as Parker
Past Lives
2023
as Arthur
Big George Foreman
2023
as Desmond
Call Jane
2022
as Detective Chilmark
Showing Up
2022
as Sean
18½
2022
as Paul
Super Pumped: The Battle for Uber
2022
as John Zimmer
The Many Saints of Newark
2021
as Silvio Dante
Lansky
2021
as Young Meyer Lansky
The Birthday Cake
2021
as Cousin Joey
First Cow: A Place in This World
2020
as Self
Sylvie's Love
2020
as Sid
First Cow
2019
as Cookie
The Umbrella Academy
2019
as Leonard Peabody
Overlord
2018
as Private First Class Lyle Tibbet
Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan
2018
as Victor Polizzi
Marshall
2017
as Irwin Friedman
War Machine
2017
as Cory Staggart
Crisis in Six Scenes
2016
as Alan Brockman
Don't Worry Baby
2016
as Robert Lang
The Finest Hours
2016
as Ervin Maske
Angie Tribeca
2016
as Snick
The Big Short
2015
as Charlie Geller
Carol
2015
as Dannie McElroy
Unbroken
2014
as Frank A. Tinker
Orange Is the New Black
2013
as Vince Muccio
Deep Powder
2013
as Cota
Not Fade Away
2012
as Douglas Damiano
Liberal Arts
2012
as Dean
Person of Interest
2011
as Carl Elias (Age 22)
Body of Proof
2011
as Chuck Foster
Down the Shore
2011
as Martin
My Soul to Take
2010
as Alex
The Box
2009
as Charles
Taking Chance
2009
as Rich Brewer
Assassination of a High School President
2008
as Cipriato
The Brave One
2007
as Ethan
The Life Before Her Eyes
2007
as Michael Patrick
Bomb
2007
Conviction
2006
as Jiggy
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
1999
as Andrew Hingham
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
1999
as Keith Musio
Law & Order
1990
as Nathan Gersh
The Girl from Köln
as Keith Jarrett
Omaha
as Dad
The Agency
as Owen